A roofing company owner in Brisbane sat across from me two years ago and slid a spreadsheet across the table. He had been paying an SEO agency $1,500 per month for eight months. His rankings had not moved. When I looked at his backlink report, I understood why immediately.
He had 340 new backlinks. Every single one came from low-quality directory submissions, blog comment sections, and web 2.0 profiles on free blogging platforms. His agency had been building links relentlessly. They were just building the wrong kind.
That conversation changed how I talk to clients about backlinks. Volume is not the metric that matters. Type and quality are. A single editorial backlink from a relevant industry publication outperforms 500 directory submissions in every competitive keyword test I have ever run.
If you want expert help with this, explore our Link Building Services and Guest Post Links — we work with service businesses across the UK, Dubai, and UAE.
Most guides about backlink types read like a taxonomy lesson. This one is different. Each type below is ranked by the actual SEO impact I have observed across real campaigns, with honest commentary about when each type is worth pursuing and when it is a waste of time and budget.
Starting at the Bottom: Backlink Types With Minimal SEO Impact
Type 1: Web 2.0 Profile Links (Weakest)
Web 2.0 profile links come from creating accounts on free platforms like Blogger, WordPress.com, Tumblr, or Weebly and adding your website link to your profile. These were used heavily in the early 2010s because they were easy to build at scale and Google had not yet devalued them.
Today they contribute almost nothing to rankings. Google recognises these platforms as link repositories and has significantly reduced the authority weight it assigns to links from them. In the 340-link portfolio I described above, roughly 80 links were web 2.0 profiles. Their collective impact on rankings was indistinguishable from zero.
The only scenario where web 2.0 links add minor value is as part of a tiered link building strategy where they support higher-quality links rather than pointing directly at your target pages. Even then, the effort-to-return ratio is poor compared to almost every other link type on this list.
Type 2: Blog Comment Links
Blog comment links are backlinks generated by leaving comments on other websites with your URL included. Most blog comment links are nofollow, meaning they carry a tag that tells search engines not to pass authority through them. Even the ones that are dofollow typically come from low-authority pages with no topical relevance to your site.
The practice of mass blog commenting for links is widely recognised by Google as a manipulation tactic. Patterns of identical-looking comment profiles pointing to the same domain are something Google's spam detection handles routinely.
Legitimate blog commenting, where you engage genuinely with content in your niche and add a link as part of a real contribution, has marginal brand awareness value but negligible ranking impact. It is not worth pursuing as a link building strategy.
Type 3: Generic Directory Links
Generic directory links come from online business directories that accept any business regardless of industry or location. Think of broad submission sites that list thousands of businesses across every possible category with no editorial review.
These carry more weight than web 2.0 profile links because they at least represent a real business listing format. But Google has significantly discounted mass-submission directories over the past decade. A listing on a low-traffic, low-authority directory that accepts anyone adds minimal ranking signal.
The exception worth noting is niche-specific directories and local directories with genuine authority and traffic. A plumber listed on a real plumbing industry directory with actual users is a different signal from a plumber listed on a generic directory that nobody visits. Niche and local directories belong in a higher tier and are discussed later in this list.
The Middle Ground: Backlink Types Worth Pursuing Selectively
Type 4: Forum and Community Links
Forum links come from participating in online communities such as Reddit, Quora, specialist industry forums, and niche Facebook groups. When done authentically, these links carry modest but real value because they come from platforms with genuine authority and engaged audiences.
The key word is authentically. Forum participation that adds genuine value to a discussion and naturally includes a relevant link is a legitimate and sometimes surprisingly effective tactic. Spammy forum dropping with no contextual relevance is spam and Google treats it accordingly.
Reddit links from relevant subreddits and Quora answers that rank in Google search results carry the most value in this category. A well-written Quora answer on a topic directly related to your service that ranks for a long-tail keyword and includes your link is driving referral traffic and passing a small but real authority signal simultaneously.
Type 5: Niche and Local Directory Links
Niche and local directory links sit significantly above generic directories because they carry topical and geographic relevance signals. A dental practice listed on a verified dental association directory is telling Google something meaningful about its industry relevance. A landscaping company listed in a city Chamber of Commerce directory is sending a geographic relevance signal that generic directories cannot produce.
For local businesses specifically, citations on authoritative local directories including Yelp, Google Business Profile, Bing Places, Apple Maps, and industry-specific platforms form a foundational layer of local SEO authority that no other link type can fully replace. These are not glamorous links. They are essential ones.
The ranking impact of niche and local directory links is moderate but consistent. They rarely move rankings dramatically on their own but they create the citation and authority foundation that higher-quality links build on top of. Skipping this foundation to chase guest posts is a strategic mistake I see regularly.
Type 6: Social Media Profile Links
Social media profile links from platforms like LinkedIn, Facebook Business, Instagram, Twitter, and YouTube are mostly nofollow. That means they technically do not pass authority the way editorial dofollow links do.
They still matter for three reasons. First, they are trust signals. A business with active, consistent social profiles is perceived as more credible by both Google and users. Second, Google does index social profiles and uses them as part of its entity understanding of a business. Third, high-traffic social content occasionally earns secondary backlinks when other publishers reference or share it.
Social media profile links are worth maintaining for brand completeness but should not consume link building budget or be counted as ranking-driving links in any meaningful strategic sense.
The Links That Actually Move Rankings
Type 7: Resource Page Links
Resource page links come from pages specifically designed to curate useful links for a topic. Many websites in every niche maintain a resources page, a tools page, or a recommended reading page. Getting your content or tool listed on a relevant resource page earns a link from a page whose entire purpose is to link out to valuable external resources.
These links tend to come from pages with genuine topical authority and real user intent. Someone visiting a resource page for digital marketing tools is actively looking for useful links. Being listed there signals relevance to Google and drives real referral traffic to your site.
The outreach approach for resource page links is direct and transparent: identify relevant resource pages in your niche, confirm that your content or tool genuinely belongs there, and pitch the page owner with a concise explanation of why your link adds value to their existing list. Acceptance rates are lower than other tactics but the links earned are consistently high quality.
Type 8: Niche Edit Links (Link Insertions)
Niche edits are backlinks inserted into existing published content on relevant websites. A niche edit on a well-trafficked article that has been indexed for two years and has its own backlink profile passes significantly more authority than a fresh guest post on the same domain because the page has accumulated equity over time.
The ranking impact of a quality niche edit is strong and tends to materialise faster than guest posts because the host page already carries established authority. For campaigns with a 60 to 90 day ranking target, well-placed niche edits consistently produce the fastest movement of any link type I have tested.
Quality control is essential here. Niche edits placed on genuinely relevant, high-traffic pages are powerful ranking tools. Niche edits placed on pages with no traffic and no topical relevance are closer to Type 1 and Type 2 links in actual impact, regardless of what the domain authority metric says.
Type 9: Guest Post Links
Guest post links are backlinks earned by writing original content published on another website in your niche. A guest post on a genuine website with real editorial standards and a real audience is one of the most reliable and sustainable link building tactics available.
The ranking impact of guest posts is strong and tends to be durable. Well-placed guest posts accumulate their own backlinks and traffic over time, which increases the authority they pass to your site on an ongoing basis. The best guest post links I have built are still contributing to rankings two to three years after publication.
Guest posts take longer to produce ranking movement than niche edits because new pages take time to build page-level authority. But they compound in value in a way that niche edits typically do not. For campaigns focused on long-term authority building, guest posts are the backbone of a sustainable link profile.
The Strongest Backlink Type in SEO
Type 10: Editorial Links (Strongest)
Editorial links are backlinks earned without any direct arrangement, payment, or outreach. A journalist cites your research in an article. A prominent blogger references your tool. A popular website links to your content because it is the best resource on that topic. These are editorial links and they are the most powerful ranking signals in Google's algorithm.
The reason editorial links carry such extraordinary weight is that they cannot be manufactured through standard outreach tactics. They represent a genuine third-party endorsement from a source with no financial or relationship incentive to link to you. Google's entire original PageRank algorithm was built on the assumption that editorial links represent real votes of confidence.
Earning editorial links requires content or tools that are genuinely worth linking to. Original research with proprietary data, free tools that solve a real problem, comprehensive guides that become industry references, and newsworthy statistics that journalists cite in their stories are the most reliable editorial link magnets. This is harder than outreach-based link building but the links it produces are significantly more valuable and far more difficult for competitors to replicate.
The Brisbane roofing company, by the way, replaced their mass-submission campaign with a strategy focused on local press coverage, Chamber of Commerce links, guest posts on home improvement publications, and one piece of original research about roofing costs across Australian cities. Within five months they ranked in the local 3-pack for their primary keywords. Twelve months later they held three first-page positions for competitive organic terms. The total number of new links was 31. The difference in type was everything.
Frequently Asked Questions About Backlink Types and SEO Impact
Nofollow links do not pass PageRank directly. However, Google has stated that it treats nofollow as a hint rather than a directive, meaning some nofollow links from highly authoritative sources may still influence rankings to a small degree. More practically, nofollow links from high-traffic sources drive real referral traffic and contribute to brand visibility that can generate secondary editorial links over time. They are worth having but should not be the focus of a ranking-focused link building strategy.
There is no universal number. The answer is however many high-quality, topically relevant links it takes to outperform the pages currently ranking above you. Use tools like Ahrefs or Semrush to analyse the backlink profiles of pages ranking in positions one through three for your target keyword. That analysis tells you the actual link quantity and quality threshold you need to compete, not a generalised estimate.
Paid backlinks that are disclosed as sponsored and use nofollow or sponsored link attributes are compliant with Google's guidelines. Paid backlinks that pass PageRank without disclosure violate Google's link spam policies. The risk is not in paying for placement but in whether the link passes authority in a way that Google's guidelines require to be disclosed. Guest post placements on genuine websites with real audiences occupy a grey area that many reputable agencies operate within without penalty.
Domain authority is a third-party metric created by Moz to estimate the ranking strength of a website. Ahrefs has a similar metric called domain rating. Neither is a Google metric and neither should be used as the sole measure of link quality. A website with domain authority 60 and zero organic traffic is a weaker link source than a website with domain authority 35 and 20,000 monthly visitors. Use authority metrics as one data point alongside traffic, relevance, and editorial quality.
Google typically crawls and indexes new backlinks within days to weeks of them going live. The ranking impact, however, takes longer to fully materialise. Niche edits on established pages often show ranking influence within four to eight weeks. Guest posts on new pages typically show meaningful impact at the eight to sixteen week mark as the host page builds its own authority. High-authority editorial links can produce faster movement but their timing is less predictable.
Both matter for different reasons. Homepage links build overall domain authority that benefits your entire website. Inner page links build specific authority for those pages and are more directly impactful for ranking that page's target keywords. A balanced link building strategy builds links to both. For competitive keyword targets, links pointing directly to the specific page you want to rank tend to produce faster and more targeted ranking movement.
Yes, in specific circumstances. A sudden unnatural spike in low-quality backlinks from irrelevant sources is a pattern Google's spam detection is designed to identify. Building links at a velocity that looks unnatural relative to your domain's historical link acquisition rate, or acquiring large quantities of links from the same source or network, carries penalty risk. Quality over quantity and a natural-looking velocity are the principles that keep a backlink profile safe.
A toxic backlink is a link from a spammy, penalised, or irrelevant website that may signal to Google that your site is part of a link manipulation scheme. Google's algorithms handle the vast majority of low-quality links automatically by ignoring them rather than penalising the recipient site. Manual disavow through Google Search Console is only recommended when you have received a manual action penalty specifically citing unnatural links or when your site has a clear pattern of spammy link acquisition that you need to actively address.
Most social media backlinks are nofollow and do not directly pass PageRank. Their value lies in referral traffic, brand visibility, and the secondary editorial links that viral or widely shared content can generate. Social media platforms are not link building targets in the traditional sense but maintaining complete, accurate, and active profiles on major platforms contributes to your overall web presence and entity authority in ways that support broader SEO performance.
Topical relevance. A link from a website in your niche or from content directly related to your service area passes a relevance signal that a high-authority but unrelated website cannot provide. Google uses backlinks not just to measure authority but to understand what topics and entities a website is associated with. A roofing company with backlinks from roofing industry publications, home improvement websites, and local construction associations sends a much clearer topical relevance signal than the same number of links from unrelated high-authority domains.
The Type of Backlink You Build Matters More Than the Number You Collect
The Brisbane roofing company's story is not unusual. I have seen versions of it across dozens of audits: businesses spending real money on links that are doing almost nothing while the competitor above them in search results has half as many links and ranks comfortably ahead. The difference is always in link type, not link count.
Start with the foundation. Niche directories, local citations, and resource page links build the base. Layer guest posts on top for sustained authority growth. Pursue niche edits when you need faster movement. And invest in content that earns editorial links by being genuinely worth citing. That is the sequence that produces compounding, defensible rankings rather than the temporary illusion of activity that cheap link volume creates.
What does your current backlink profile look like? If you have never audited the type breakdown of your existing links, that is the most valuable 30 minutes you can spend on your SEO this week.
Want Results Like This for Your Business?
Get a free Local SEO audit — we will show you exactly what is holding your rankings back and the fastest path to the Google map pack.
Talk to a Local SEO Specialist →